Overview
I’ve been a fan of Greta Van Fleet since their first EP, and their 2021 album “The Battle at Garden’s Gate” was my Number 1 Album of that year. So when they release a new record it gets my attention. I liked the songs and performances on their last record, Starcatcher, but I was disappointed with the strange production and odd mix.
Palace for the People, released October 9, features 13 songs of nonstop grooving hard rock, spacey interludes and imaginative lyrics. I thought it would be an interesting album to review, however, because it’s been a curious listen. The first time I put it in I thought it sounded very monochromatic. Every song had the same sound: dark tones, wide and thick but indistinct bass, and a rhythmic consistency from end to end. My first impression was “60 minutes of ‘Achilles Last Stand’.” The more I listened, though, the more I got out of it and the more I heard. The record has grown on me over time.
Songs and Highlights
The album opens with an instrumental interlude “Into The Beginning” with piano, strings and tribal drums, with layers of chanting vocals on top. The first proper song is “Tear it Down,” with a great riff and the strongest chorus of the album. I must have listened to this song five times before I realized there was a spacey, psychedelic bridge. Curious.
The driving riffs and propelling rhythms continue with “Heart and the Beat.” It’s another song where there is a bridge, but it seems to get lost. A lot of the record is like this. Two songs later we get “Field of Stars,” which has a similar quality. Maybe the choruses aren’t strong enough, or don’t pop enough sonically, so everything outside of the bridge tends to blend together.
One of my favorite songs is the acoustic-driven “Boughten Bliss.” It provides a needed respite from the driving rock, and the vocals are fantastic. The upbeat “Play Your Games” starts with a jumpy acoustic part, and segues that into a jagged electric guitar that provides a perfect bed for Josh’s trademark soaring vocals on the chorus. “Touch Again” starts with swirling guitars and transitions into a thunderous riff propelled by the bass and drums. The “Wake Up!” line in the chorus grabs your attention. It’s a standout song on the album.
Another of my favorites is “Lost in the Golden.” If any song grabbed me on first listen, this was it. Pounding drums propel a unique electric guitar part and some of the strongest lyrics and vocals on the record. Rhythmically it’s very similar to the rest of the album, but the choruses pop a lot more, and the end of the choruses bring the intensity down for a few bars before it goes back into the aggressiveness of the subsequent verses. Those dynamics aren’t as present in much of the album.
The piano-driven “Saw You Stand” was one of the earliest songs released, and it’s nice to see the band branching out a bit. It showcases a tender side of Josh’s vocals that hasn’t really come out in previous albums, and the soaring chorus brings it home.
Standouts
- Lost in the Golden
- Touch Again
- Boughten Bliss
- Tear It Down
- Saw You Stand
The Mix
While the mix is better than Starcatcher, there are still some head scratching choices. On one of the songs the guitar solo is buried at the same level as the rhythm guitars. It doesn’t pop. Sam Kiszka is a great bass player, but the recorded tone here is often more of a low rumble, hard to pick out. I’d loved to have heard a more distinct bass tone that better drives the songs and showcases his playing. On some of the acoustic numbers like Boughten Bliss, the acoustic guitars have such a similar quality as the electric guitar it’s almost hard to tell there are acoustic songs at all.
Conclusion
So how do I rate it now, after repeated listening? It’s absolutely grown on me more dramatically than other albums that didn’t immediately capture my attention. It was interesting how much of this record took several listens to hear. There’s more variety and dynamics than I first noticed, and most of the tunes would be fantastic live. It’s still a very dark sounding album, the mix isn’t particularly clear, and while there are standouts, the songs aren’t as strong as the last few albums. In the end I do like it the record, it’s good, but it’s not great. I’d love to see the band work with a different produce and mixer and translate their energy and creativity in to more listenable platter. B-





























